I gave Tomato Pie Cafe in Lititz five out of five stars in August of 2014.
Tomato Pie Cafe
23 N Broad St
Lititz, PA 17543
What an amazing gem to find! We stopped briefly in Lititz for Wilbur’s chocolates and popped across the street for a snack, discovered patio seating out back and had a spectacularly lovely meal!
We started with watermelon and serrano soup and then I had grilled peaches on arugula salad with goat cheese and peach pie for dessert. Wonderful staff and location on a beautiful day. The child’s grilled cheese sandwich my friend’s daughter enjoyed was made with very colorful bread! Fun place and a delightful visit. We will be back.
Update: Since that magical original visit, we discovered a second location in Harrisburg, which was also very good – but did not have the magic of the one in Lititz.